0out of 100
Excellent

2021 Bellefontaine Street, Indianapolis, IN, USA

Score Breakdown
Value40/40
Cash Flow35/35
Location12/25
$
$225,000
%
$45,000 cash at risk up front
87
2021 Bellefontaine Street, Indianapolis, IN, USA
5 bd1 ba

Excellent

87/100

This is a solid deal — priced below the local market with healthy equity after repairs. Watch that the rental yield is thin the neighborhood scores low.

Highlights
  • 34% below area price per sqft
  • $165k potential equity (40%)
  • $163/mo positive cash flow
Watch-outs
  • Cap rate only 4.87%
  • Neighborhood scores 55/100

Price vs. Market

Good
Your offer
$136/sqft
Area avg
$240/sqft
43% below market average
Your offer
$225,000
At market rate
$397,200

ARV Assessment

GoodLive · LLM + comps
ARV Low
$462k
Est. ARV
$539k
ARV High
$624k
Total Investment
$225k
Est. ARV
$539k
Rehab Cost
$5k
Potential Equity
$314k
Comparable Reasoning

The After-Repair Value (ARV) range for the subject property is estimated to be between $461,760 and $624,240 after full renovation, based on high-quality comparables in the same neighborhood.

2 more details
Condition Assessment

Property presents in turnkey condition. Estimated rehab of $5k covers minor refresh and make-ready.

Methodology

Sales-comparison approach using 6 live sold comps from Realtor.com (filtered from 10 candidates), evaluated by LLM for proximity, recency, and renovation quality.

High confidence6 live sold comps

Comparable Sales

6 comps
2043 Bellefontaine St, Indianapolis, IN
95% match
$472,000
$240/sqft
2043 Bellefontaine St, Indianapolis, IN
3 2.5 1,9700.04 misold May 2026
2141 Bellefontaine St, Indianapolis, IN
75% match
$299,999
2141 Bellefontaine St, Indianapolis, IN
0.18 misold Aug 2022
2023 Broadway St, Indianapolis, IN
85% match
$597,000
$224/sqft
2023 Broadway St, Indianapolis, IN
4 2.5 2,6600.19 misold May 2026
1826 Rosette Way, Indianapolis, IN
90% match
$545,000
$256/sqft
1826 Rosette Way, Indianapolis, IN
3 2.5 2,1270.24 misold May 2026
2020 Columbia Ave, Indianapolis, IN
85% match
$669,375
$211/sqft
2020 Columbia Ave, Indianapolis, IN
4 3.5 3,1760.26 misold May 2023
1806 Alvord St, Indianapolis, IN
85% match
$355,000
$264/sqft
1806 Alvord St, Indianapolis, IN
2 2.5 1,3440.27 misold May 2026
ARV & comps — see the full analysis on Offa

Rental Income

GoodLive · 2 comps
25th pct
$2,500
Median /mo
$4,000
75th pct
$5,500
Monthly Rent
$4,000
Annual Rent
$48k
Rental Yield
21.3%
Cap Rate
11.7%
Market Assessment

Median area rent is $4,000/mo based on 2 comps. Standard deviation $2,121/mo indicates varied pricing in the area.

2 more details
Comparable Reasoning

Based on 2 comparable rentals within 50.0 miles of similar houses, monthly rents range from $2,500 (25th percentile) to $5,500 (75th percentile), with a median of $4,000.

Methodology

Median + 25th/75th percentile of comparable Realtor.com rentals within 50.0 miles. Standard deviation: $2,121.

Based on 2 rental comps within 50.0 mi · σ $2,121
Rental analysis — see the full analysis on Offa

Financing Calculator

GoodLive rate · Freddie Mac
Using the current 6.49% 30-yr fixed national average (as of 2026-06-25). Adjust below to match your quote.
Price
$225,000
Loan
$180,000
$45,000
%
%
↓ Monthly Costs
↑ Income Potential
Principal + Interest$1,137/mo
Estimated Rent$4,000/mo
Taxes + Insurance$360/mo
Cash-on-Cash Return60.11%
Total Payment
$1,497/mo
Monthly Cash Flow
+$2,503/mo
Positive cash flow: $2,503/mo

Neighborhood Profile

Needs WorkLive Data
CTier
Emerging Neighborhood51/100
Composite socioeconomic score
Median Income
$61k
Median Home
$420k
Median Rent
$1,258/mo
Homeownership
28.8%
Vacancy
13.48%
Population
20,331
Score Breakdown
Income & Wealth
47
Housing Market
43
Education
91
Employment
70
Stability
11
Infrastructure
65
Neighborhood data — see the full analysis on Offa

City Population

GoodLive Data
Indianapolis, IN
10-year population trend
+5.6% / decade
City Population
882,043
Density / sq mi
2,443
Area (sq mi)
361
Within 1 Mile
5,349
1-Mile Density
2,768
Trend Years
2014–2023

Get alerts for deals like this in Indianapolis

We'll email you when matching off-market deals hit Offa's marketplace.

Similar Off-Market Deals Nearby